Looking for recommendations on how to proceed with getting the Front Fenders repaired on my 2016 Polaris Slingshot. Does anyone have a recommendation on an auto body shop that can repair these fenders in Tampa bay FL area?

I believe that all the body panels on the SS are ABS plastic. There are ABS resins (example Easy ABS Resin) to perform the repair. As far as a recommendation for a body shop local to Tampa, Florida, I suggest you do a Yelp or Google search for your local area.

While I have nothing helpful to contribute... Welcome fellow Tampa area Slingshotter.

Search this site on how to remove body parts --- and find the best shop in your area.

It would probably be easier, faster and cheaper to just buy a used pair from any of the salvage yards in Florida that have damaged Slingshot wrecks in stock.

Whichever way you go, compare the quotes you might get for repair against the cost of replacement. All of the panels can be bought and replaced for a price. Welcome to the Show!